May 3, 2008
The Home News
http://www.mycentraljersey.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20080503/SPECIAL03/805040312&template=printart
Equipment, training rise to new heights
By JOSHUA BURD
STAFF WRITER
How do you fight a fire in a 24-story building when your ladder only reaches the ninth story?
Firefighters face countless hazards when responding to a blaze in a high-rise — defined as a structure at least 75 feet tall — including physical stress, panicked evacuees and sometimes unpredictable conditions.
The number of towering structures in Central Jersey has risen in recent years thanks to several spurts of new development. With 105 high rises in Middlesex, Somerset and Union counties, this increasingly upward growth adds to the challenges to local fire departments.
“We hope that we never get those types of fires,” said George Borek, first vice president of the Professional Firefighters Association of New Jersey. “But the reality is when you get them, I’m sure a lot of departments are flying by the seat of their pants.”
But even with the treacherous nature of high-rise blazes, local fire companies say they are prepared to meet the challenges.
Though the state cannot regulate any department’s ability to fight high-rise fires, municipal fire departments across-the-board all set high standards for training, planning and building-safety inspections, all designed to prevent or prepare for the worst.
“They’re constantly training, keeping up with all the changes that are coming out. A lot of properties in the county have been developed now,” Middlesex County Fire Marshal Michael Gallagher said. “It adds more runs to the fire departments, whether it’s to false alarms or to large-scale fires. It’s increasing every year.”
Massive response
A recent incident in Monmouth County illustrates the demands of a high-rise operation.
More than 100 firefighters responded to Munroe Towers in Asbury Park in September 2007 for a blaze that broke out on the 14th floor of that high-rise apartment building. Firefighters were required to climb the stairs in order to battle the fire and rescue several residents who were trapped in their apartments.
A department responding to any high-rise fire is almost invariably in need of mutual aid, officials say. Because of the physically taxing nature of the operation — carrying equipment up many flights of stairs and contending with dangerous conditions at the top of the building — fire departments say fresh bodies are indispensable in a taller building.
“In the end it takes manpower,” Borek said. “Without manpower, you’re not putting out that fire.”
Dozens of firefighters are required in several key areas — in the building, on the ground and in the firehouses vacated by the departments responding, according Lt. Mike Daley of Monroe Township Fire District 3.
Daley, who is also an instructor at the Middlesex County Fire Academy, said a response to a high-rise fire includes at least four floors of operation.
The “attack” originates from the floor below the blaze, where at least two teams of firefighters hook into the standpipe before carrying their hoses up to the fire.
Two floors below the fire, responders may set up what Daley calls a “resource” or “rehab” floor, serving as a place where firefighters can be rotated, checked and rehydrated, as well as a place to store spare equipment such as air bottles and hose lines.
Other firefighters are assigned to search-and-rescue teams, checking the fire floor and the floor above, then working their way down from the top floor.
A department is also likely to set up a command center on the ground, where a commander is coordinating the fire-fighting effort, Daley said.
Meanwhile, additional firefighters are operating the engine to pump water into the building’s standpipe system.
“A lot of tactical decisions have to be made,” he said. “It’s a lot tougher than just fighting a fire in a house.”
Equipment needs
“Anything that we would need, we have. There’s no real magical spell that makes it easier,” said James Varrick, chief of the East Brunswick Independent Fire Company. “We’re just applying the tools we have in a different way.”
Varrick, whose department covers the 24-story “twin towers” off Route 18, echoes the consensus among fire officials — that high-rise firefighting, with respect to equipment, is essentially the same as in a ground situation.
But in order to get their gear up into a building, fire companies set up “high-rise packs” containing hose lengths, valves, nozzles and several other tools used to carry out their operation.
When the elevator is not available — a likely scenario — the equipment is inevitably being lugged up several flights of stairs. For at least some departments, high-rise packs contain equipment made with lighter-weight metals “so you don’t beat the guy up carrying them to the upper floors,” according to John Hauss, director of fire prevention in Franklin.
Other items in a high-rise pack include spare air bottles and search-and-rescue equipment.
Lessons from N.Y.C
A fire at the former Deutsche Bank building in New York City drew enormous attention in summer 2007 when two city firefighters were killed trying to extinguish the blaze. Investigators determined that a 42-foot piece of standpipe was missing from the Ground Zero high-rise, forcing firefighters to use ropes to raise lengths of hose up from the street.
Among several other factors that were compounded by missed inspections, the failing standpipe highlighted one of the key building features that have to maintained to stave off catastrophe.
“If that standpipe isn’t maintained, if it’s broken, if it’s clogged or anything, the fire department is not going to get water up there,” Gallagher said. “And that’s a big issue that has to be talked over with the building superintendent.”
The state’s Uniform Construction Code requires yearly inspections in high-rises, with checks for proper upkeep of standpipes, sprinkler systems, orderly stairwells and other key areas.
Meanwhile, fire-code officials are involved from the very beginning of construction to ensure that safety features are included.
But fire officials stress that there are always unknowns at a high-rise fire — the windows at the top of a building may not open, ventilation systems may not shut down.
And there is no telling how the occupants of the building will react during an evacuation, even when procedures call for them to stay in an unaffected part of the building, Gallagher said.
“You can have the best policy in place — but when there’s a fire, people are going to want to get out,” he said. “So no matter what you practice with them, they’re going to come out of that building.”
Focus on training
Despite the uncertainty of battling a high-rise blaze, local fire departments say they train for as many scenarios as possible.
Firefighters from throughout the state train at fire academies in both Middlesex and Somerset counties. A five-story training tower at the Middlesex facility allows veteran firefighters and cadets to simulate a response to a high-rise fire, in an exercise that includes climbing stairs, hooking into a standpipe, and performing search-and-rescue.
“It’s not only the initial training, but they keep coming back to refresh,” said Bill Petry, the senior fire instructor at the Sayreville facility.
Fire officials say familiarity with building dynamics is also paramount. Two equally important practices include having their departments do regular walk-throughs at their local high-rises and planning ahead for such operations.
Sprinklers
About 490, or nearly half of all high-rises in the state, lack adequate sprinkler protection, according to the New Jersey Fire Sprinkler Advisory Board.
Of all the variables at a high-rise fire, many fire officials say sprinklers make the biggest difference.
But several high rises in Central Jersey where built before 1987, when all new high rises were required to have full sprinkler protection. Now local departments are pushing for the state Department of Community Affairs to adopt a proposal that would require a retrofit of all buildings without a full sprinkler system.
“The bottom line is that this is going to save lives,” said Hillsborough Chief Fire Marshal Chris Weniger, whose township includes the three Claremont Towers, which were erected in the 1970s. “We’re trying to avoid having a tragedy for everyone.”
While municipalities are less visible in the debate between sprinkler advocates and tenant associations, which point to the financial burden of retrofits, Weniger called the local fire departments the “silent majority.”
“Last time I checked,” Weniger said. “We don’t put a price on human life.”